Discussion about this post

User's avatar
GavinRuneblade's avatar

Question: how is there enough carbon to matter? Volume wise, Venus just doesn't have much compared to the mass of the sun. Even if all of the carbon atoms were turned into astrophage and moved to the sun, that's smaller than a single sun spot. A big sunspot is larger than the full volume of Venus. And while there's a lot of carbon in the atmosphere, it's less than 1% of the planet's atoms. How is it enough to dim the star?

Catalyst not ingredient is my assumption, but I don't remember reading the answer. Was it hand waved or did I just miss it?

Rob Melton's avatar

Informative and entertaining, and exactly the way to draw students into the subject matter! I took a class in environmental science that riveted my attention, along with journalism, and I ended up with a B.S. in Journalism and minors in English and Political Science. Kind of unusual, but the newspaper in eastern Oregon needed a science reporter to cover nuclear power, farming, rivers, port districts, and small towns. Eventually when I pivoted to teaching with an M.S. in Education C&I. So of course I became a high school journalism and photography teacher. (My dad was a teacher.) And eventually English, the way you describe teaching. It makes all the difference.

No posts

Ready for more?